Statutory Demands QLD
Statutory demand lawyers, Queensland
A statutory demand gives a company 21 days, and that deadline cannot be extended by the creditor, by agreement, or by the court. If one has been served on you, the clock started the day it arrived. We act on both sides and we move at the speed the section requires.
01
Start with the Fast-Track Assessment
Tell us who owes what and how long it has been outstanding. It takes about a minute, and it decides whether a letter is enough on its own.
02
The 21 days, and the two ways companies lose them
A creditor's statutory demand is a formal notice under section 459E of the Corporations Act 2001 requiring a company to pay a debt of at least $4,000 within 21 days. That much is settled, it is on every page that ranks for this term, and the Federal Court publishes its own information sheet on it. We have linked it below rather than rewrite it.
The definition is not where this goes wrong. The deadline is.
Twenty-one days from service. Not from the date typed on the demand, and not from the day somebody got around to opening it.
It is not extended because the office was closed over Christmas, because your accountant was away, or because the creditor said on the phone that they would give you longer. It is not extended by the court either. In David Grant & Co v Westpac the High Court held that section 459G confers no power to extend the 21 days at all, and nothing since has softened it.
There is a second trap inside the first, and it is the one that costs companies their challenge. Filing the application is not enough. Section 459G requires that the application AND its supporting affidavit both be filed and served on the creditor within the 21 days. Filed on day 20 and served on day 22 is out of time, and out of time here is not a delay to be excused: in David Grant the High Court held the period defines the court's jurisdiction, so a late application is no application at all.
03
A demand has been served. There are four things you can do
Three of them end the demand. The fourth ends the argument, and not in your favour.
We will tell you which of the four we think applies, including when that answer is the first one. A demand on a debt you genuinely owe and can pay is not a case, it is an invoice with a deadline attached. If the debt is genuinely owed and the company simply cannot pay it, the question is no longer the demand: read bankruptcy and insolvency instead, because the directors' own position is live from that point.
04
Four grounds to set a demand aside
They are not alternatives to be picked from. Each is a different argument with a different test, and the first decides most applications.
01
s 459H(1)(a)
A genuine dispute about the debt
The common one, and the bar is lower than people expect. You do not have to prove you will win the dispute. The test, from Eyota Pty Ltd v Hanave Pty Ltd, is a plausible contention requiring investigation - much the same idea as a serious question to be tried - and the court will not try to resolve the dispute itself on the application. What the bar being low does not mean is that saying so is enough. The same case is clear that a patently feeble legal argument, or an assertion of facts unsupported by evidence, does not get there. Nor does a dispute manufactured on day 19: one raised in writing months earlier reads very differently.
02
s 459H(1)(b)
An offsetting claim
A genuine claim the company has against the creditor, whether or not it arises out of the same dealings. It does not have to defeat the debt. The court works out the substantiated amount by subtracting the offsetting total, and if what is left falls below the statutory minimum the demand is set aside altogether rather than reduced.
03
s 459J(1)(a)
A defect causing substantial injustice
A misstated amount, a debt described so loosely the company cannot tell what is claimed, an affidavit sworn by somebody with no knowledge of the debt. A defect on its own is not enough, which is the part that catches people out: section 459J(2) says a demand is not to be set aside merely because of a defect. It has to have caused substantial injustice.
04
s 459J(1)(b)
Some other reason
The residual ground. An abuse of process, a debt that is not yet due and payable, or a demand used as leverage against a company that is plainly solvent - which is what the court was dealing with in Owners Corp SP66609 v Perpetual Trustee Co, where it observed that a demand should not be used that way and that indemnity costs may follow. It is rarely run on its own and rarely succeeds on its own, but it is the ground that catches a demand which is technically in order and still should not have been issued.
The grounds have to be in the affidavit you serve inside the 21 days. A ground you think of afterwards is generally not available to you, so the affidavit is the application - not a formality attached to it. It is also the reason a letter of demand matters more than it looks: a dispute the other side put in writing months ago is evidence of a genuine dispute, and a creditor holding that letter in their own file should not be issuing a statutory demand at all.
05
Issuing one, and the five questions to answer first
A statutory demand is not a debt collection tool. It is an insolvency tool that happens to collect debts, and the difference matters because the consequences of getting it wrong run the other way.
Issue one on a debt the other side genuinely disputes and the likely outcome is that it is set aside and you pay their costs. Deploying a demand where a real controversy exists, or against a company that is plainly solvent, has been treated as an abuse of process, and in Owners Corp SP66609 v Perpetual Trustee Co the court noted that indemnity costs may follow. That is a long way from a letter that did not work.
07
Why choose Odyssey Legal?
Imagine the relief of finally knowing your legal troubles are in expert hands. Whether it's recovering money owed through our Letter of Demand or pursuing your rights through legal proceedings, you'll leave our consultation with certainty about your path forward and the confidence that comes from having expert litigation lawyers protecting your interests.
What that means in practice
Fast-Track Assessment
Find out how many of the 21 days you have left
Five questions, about a minute. It tells us which side of a statutory demand you are on, how many of the 21 days are left, and what can still be done with them - and if the answer is that you should simply pay the debt, we will say that too.
If a demand has already been served, call (07) 5370 8759 rather than filling anything in. This is the one service on the site where the form is the slower option, and the deadline does not pause while a message sits in an inbox.
Related information
Corporations Information Sheet 1, Federal Court of Australia
The court's own guide to statutory demands and winding up proceedings, and the result at position one on this search
Search ASIC's registers
Where to confirm a company's registered office before serving, or after receiving, a demand
Letter of demand
The step before this one, and the reason a demand that flushed out a written dispute can rule a statutory demand out
Debt recovery
The four-rung ladder, where a statutory demand sits on it, and what the alternatives cost
Bankruptcy and insolvency
Director duties, insolvent trading and what happens once the company cannot pay